Why AI is fuelling the volume recruitment crisis

The cost of the wrong crowd

Let’s talk about the elephant in the room - we have a volume problem. For years, the recruitment industry’s ‘more is better’ philosophy has driven a pursuit of application quantity. But here we are in 2026, in an AI driven world, where we’re suffering from an avalanche of irrelevance.

No doubt you know the feeling... You advertise a job and within 48 hours, you have 500 applications. On the surface, it looks like a win. But by the time you’ve waded through the first 100, you realize that most of these candidates are fundamentally unqualified for the role.

As we often tell our clients, a thousand wrong applications isn't a result. It’s just a longer to-do list.

The AI-fuelled funnel crisis

What’s driving this? We’re sorry to say, the primary culprit is Artificial Intelligence. While AI has incredible potential to streamline our workflows, it has also lowered the barrier to entry for candidates. With a single click, candidates can easily fire off applications to dozens of roles without really analysing whether they’re suitable or whether in fact they want the job.

This is causing the top of our funnels to overflow and is eating recruitment budgets. Many organizations are finding themselves in a vicious cycle - they spend more on job boards to get applications, then they are forced to spend even more on screening tools and manpower to sift through the sheer quantity.

The result of all that extra investment? Usually, it’s the exact same result you would have achieved with a fraction of the effort.

Consider the current industry averages; it takes roughly 180 applications to secure a single hire. Out of those 180 people, typically only five will even make it to an interview. That means more than 95% of the people engaging with your brand during the application process are essentially ‘waste’ in the funnel. This is a drain on your employer brand and your team’s morale.

Stop, move and target

To fix this, we have to stop the bleeding - how?

1. Stop the spend on low-yield, high-volume job boards that prioritize quantity over quality
2. Move the spend toward platforms and technologies that allow for precision
3. Target effectively by looking at candidates who aren't necessarily looking for you

Stopping and moving the spend is the easy bit (at least in theory). But, exactly how do you target effectively?

Unlocking the passive 73%

The biggest mistake recruiters can make is assuming that the best talent is found on a job board. The ‘active’ market is only a small slice of the pie, as we explore in this article. In reality, 73% of the total workforce is classified as ‘passive’. These are people who are currently employed, reasonably happy, but open to the right conversation. They aren't scrolling through job boards and they haven’t set up email alerts. So, if that’s your only channel, you are missing three-quarters of the talent pool.

Effective targeting means looking beyond the traditional parameters. We believe in targeting based on multiple data points, what we call the ‘omnichannel’ approach. This involves looking at everything from professional occupation data to physical location.

Defining the digital fence

One of the most powerful tools in our arsenal is what we call ‘digital fencing’ or ‘geofencing’. If you are looking for a Senior Engineer for a specific site, why are you advertising to the whole country?

By using parameters like population density and specific occupation clusters, for example looking for managers and senior officials within a specific radius of a facility, we can build a virtual fence around the places where your potential candidates are. We can identify hubs of talent and place your message exactly where those people live their lives.

Staying top of mind

In a world of noise, a single touchpoint isn't enough. You need your brand to be seen across multiple channels to break through the clutter. So, we don't just put an ad on a website. We follow the candidate's daily habits:

• They might see a digital display ad while reading their local news on a tablet
• They then see your brand on a digital out-of-home screen while walking through a city center or commuting
• Then they catch a post on their social feeds while scrolling at lunchtime
• And they see your logo on the side of a bus while commuting home

By meeting candidates where they already are, you build a level of brand familiarity that a standard job board post simply cannot match.

Final thoughts

When you stop chasing volume and start chasing precision, the numbers move in the right direction, teams are less overwhelmed and guess what, you start getting great hires!

This approach naturally reduces the volume of irrelevant applications. You stop paying your team to be professional screeners of bad resumes and start letting them be professional recruiters of top talent.

Ultimately, this is about improving your ROI. It’s time to stop worrying about how many people applied and start worrying about who they are.

About crooton

We use high tech location-based marketing to get your jobs seen by exactly the right people. Click here to find out more about what we do.

Find out more about location-based recruitment marketing

Find out how crooton’s smart recruitment marketing and advertising tech could work for your next recruitment campaign. Click here to book a free, no obligation chat with our ‘croo’.